AquaBoards.com

AquaBoards is dedicated to discussion and education about tropical aquarium fish including freshwater fish, saltwater fish, and aquarium fish keeping,

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Please note your AquaBid.com username and password will not work here. You need to register for this website if you wish to post.

#1 2010-07-20 04:35:10

BettaBetta
Member
From: Australia
Registered: 2010-03-22
Posts: 909
IP: 58.174.0.252

Rams - Need help please ....

Hi all,

I got some German Bred Blue Rams & some Balloon Gold Rams in my community tanks - was told this would be fine.

My perams are 0 Ammonia, 0 Nitrite, Nitrate 5 -10 max, PH around 7.6 - all tanks heavily planted temp 26C which is 80 I think - whatever is "right" for tropical sin general.  I haven't checked water hardness but will do so when it's daylight.

I know the PH is probably too high but have been told they'll be fine & I'm loathe to mess with it artificially (read chemically).  Tank mates are a male Betta, Rummy Nose, Corys, Bristlenose, Guppies, Mollies.

Now, I'm not sure if this is a problem, but I've noticed that ALL my Rams' little mouths open & close ten to the dozen & their little gills flap rather frantically - I've been told they "do respirate quicker than others" - but I'm worried they're stressing over the water, PH or hardness?  The new tank they'll be going into is a super wide & deep 3 footer which will have eco complete as part of the substrate & I've been told this whips up the PH even higher, gaaargh!

A couple of weeks ago I had a Balloon Gold Ram that I'd had for about a week go down with popeye & then some insidious viral disease - I got him on Metro real quick & he fought like hell to survive but succumbed and I was positively absolutely heartbroken (stupid I know).  I do weekly w/changes so it was definitely not water quality issues that took him out. 

Any help anyone can give me with regard to their rapid breathing being normal/abnormal and general upkeep to ensure their longevity & good health would be greatly appreciated.


Not usually a charitable soul?  At Kiva.org you can give "hand-ups" (loans) instead of "hand-outs" to the poor in 3rd world countries & the funds ALWAYS remain yours, to withdraw or re-loan as you see fit.  It's the BEST!!!  You can even loan to those involved in aquaculture.

Offline

 

2010-07-20 04:35:10

Google


#2 2010-07-20 05:59:40

erinmcc
Member
From: SC
Registered: 2010-01-24
Posts: 246
IP: 98.84.41.5

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

I've always heard that rams are more sensitive to water parameters as well but yours look well in line.  You can buffer the ph naturally using peat either as part of filter media or mixed in with substrate (with the new tnak using eco complete, you probably won't even notice it, just a thought)
As far as rapid breathing, are you running any type of air stone in the tank?  How is your surface agitation?  As an experiment, throw a bubbler in there and see if it helps at all.  In my opinion (and mine alone) I think 80 is a bit high for a community tropical tank.  I only keep my breeding angel pairs at 80 and everything else about 76.  The higher the temp, the less oxygen the water holds.  I know there's a scientific term but it completely eludes me at the moment.


"never trust a big butt and smile"

Offline

 

#3 2010-07-20 07:30:55

rbeauchemin
Member
From: Hohenfels, Germany
Registered: 2010-05-19
Posts: 298
IP: 217.237.32.80
Website

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

out of curiosity, what level do they swim at?  I don't keep these fish, but if they are at lower levels, is it possible your lower water is not oxygenated enough?  I only thought of this because erin mentioned the oxygenation of the water.


If you have it, share it.  If you need it, pray for it.  If you want it, work for it.

For out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks!!

Offline

 

#4 2010-07-20 11:45:41

Gecko5150
Member
From: Phoenix, Az
Registered: 2008-05-20
Posts: 264
IP: 68.98.92.2

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Erinmcc, although I have not kept rams I have been taking a hard look at them.  From my readings, I see most people say to keep them at 82-84' for them to breed.  If I am wrong, I hope someone corrects me.  But they do seem to like hotter water than normal.  Sorry that doesn't answer your question Bettabetta but thought I would point that out.

Online

 

#5 2010-07-20 13:11:20

Soft Spot for Fish/Dogs
Member
From: Past? Present? or Future?
Registered: 2008-03-05
Posts: 2136
IP: 74.195.194.67

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Hi BB.  For me the German Blue Rams would just die.  Than I had luck with the Bolivian Rams.

So I decided to try one last time with some German Blue Rams and Gold Rams, also.  The German Blue ones died for me again.  But, this time I looked at temperatures and started - yes, started - to read on the Internet what all they liked and did not.  Should have done that first but believe some of us do things backwards - grin.

The German Blues were in a tank with the temperatures of only 76.  The Gold Rams were in two tanks with temperatures of 78/79.  I know just one degree or two more and the Gold ones made it and were doing great.  The Gold Rams are now in a 29 gal with two pleco BN, some pygmy type cory cat, some Oto;s and some Bumblebee Gobies.  Plants, sinking driftwood, rocks, flower pots and believe that about covers it.  Oh, the temps in that tank are 81/82.

So I got some Electric Blues and that grow up tank was approx. 79/80 and they made it.  They are now in a 20 gal. long - temps are 81/82 with the only other critters - three LFBN.  Plants, flower pts and sinking wood - think that covers the majority of what is in that tank.  They are doing great with all their bickering and demanding to be fed.

So for me it was the temperatures.  On what to have in their tanks like company or that.  I do not know.  Others could tell you better than I could on what to put with them.  I have gotten to where I only have so many types in a tank and I call that a Community tank now- grin.

Edited to add -  I almost forgot, the Electric Blue Rams - the males swim on the bottom and chase the females where they  swim near the top.  The Gold Rams in the 29 gal swim all over that tank keeping the other male on his side.  Forgot to mention they are two pairs-   They seem to like the whole tank but mostly do have a preference for the bottom - at least half of the time - when walking by that room and going in and looking at the tank.

Last edited by Soft Spot for Fish/Dogs (2010-07-20 13:20:54)

Offline

 

#6 2010-07-20 16:03:33

vegetarian_great_white
Member
From: Michigan
Registered: 2009-09-23
Posts: 261
IP: 76.234.133.60

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

How long have you been keeping them? Is this happening since you got them or did this start after a period of normal keeping?

Are they eating well?

Are you sure you didn't introduce chlorine into the water somehow (or failed to remove)?

I think your temp is fine, if anything, should not reduce it.

I kept  rams in community tanks at Michigan tap water which is slighlty alkaline. They even bred in them. But sensitivity to alkalinity may be different depending on whether they are wild or captive-bred.

Either way, oxygenating with an airstone seems like a good first experiment.

Offline

 

#7 2010-07-20 17:20:36

BettaBetta
Member
From: Australia
Registered: 2010-03-22
Posts: 909
IP: 58.174.0.252

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Hi all,

Many thanks for your input, I was so thrilled to open up the board this morning (your night) and see so many have shared their wisdom.

Right, so many questions to answer, will do my best to cover all:

Temp is 26 celcius which is actually 78.8 F, sorry I thought it was 80F.  I have read, however, that Rams like it hot but everyone else in tank prefers this temp so presumed they'd settle with it - I have no intention of breeding.

I have a bubbler the length of the tank and, at the moment I have 2 x Eheim Canisters on it (a 2213 & a 2217) - the latter is seeding for the new big tank.  Despite the 2 x canisters blaring away there's no untoward currents because there's masses of driftwood, rocks & plants.

I was thinking of getting Peat under the EcoComplete (which will be topped with gravel) but a few people have told me it will have nil effect as there'll be little to no water circulation through it, that it's really only effective in a filter.  Problem I have with that is that as the Peat loses it's properties, gets older the PH will go up & down constantly depending on maintenance schedule & longevity of the actual Peat.

They swim just below mid-line, preferring to stay in the undergrowth.  They are not shy at all, they're all swimming end to end & checking everyone & everything out, none are looking poorly or hiding as such.

They are eating well.  No Chloramine, I age my water using a powerhead, heater & bubbler & use Prime with a wee bit of salt.

All Rams here are captive bred locally or out of Asia.  I know many of our fish importers have lost whole buys of Rams to disease and I'm thinking they must be fairly "touchy" as a breed as per Gourami's being historically full of disease & prone to collapse these days?

I guess what's worrying me most of all is their little mouths opening & closing rapidly & their gills flapping faster than any other fish I've seen (not that I've seen many), despite the fact they just merrily swim around & mix with each other.  It's weird, they show absolutely no signs of distress, unhappiness or illness.  But are they really breathing rapidly/frantically or is that what all Rams do?

Last edited by BettaBetta (2010-07-20 17:22:37)


Not usually a charitable soul?  At Kiva.org you can give "hand-ups" (loans) instead of "hand-outs" to the poor in 3rd world countries & the funds ALWAYS remain yours, to withdraw or re-loan as you see fit.  It's the BEST!!!  You can even loan to those involved in aquaculture.

Offline

 

#8 2010-07-20 17:33:13

vegetarian_great_white
Member
From: Michigan
Registered: 2009-09-23
Posts: 261
IP: 76.234.133.60

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Sounds like everything is normal. Go to youtube and search for "blue ram". Watch a few movies and see if they are breathing as rapidly as yours.

Edited breeding to breathing. My fingers have their own mind.

Last edited by vegetarian_great_white (2010-07-20 20:27:56)

Offline

 

#9 2010-07-20 22:29:10

Msdevine
Member
Registered: 2009-02-09
Posts: 1366
IP: 173.172.167.39

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Well, I have some Blue Rams and Gold Rams, and they do the same as yours. I am kinda worried too. I think I will put an air stone in there tanks. I have some baby Electric Blue Rams and they are not breathing that way. Just my older ones.
Thanks """Soft Spot for Fish/Dogs""" for the blues, I love them. Had to get some babies. I have not forgotten you.. I will write tomorrow.


I Live In My Own Little World,   But its ok "THEY" Know Me There.

Offline

 

#10 2010-07-21 00:01:09

lotsoffish
Member
From: Kenmore NY
Registered: 2007-08-24
Posts: 7748
IP: 74.77.102.122

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Rams are very prone to ich, oodinium, bloat, and whirling disease if kept at anything under about 84 degrees for extended periods of time.

Now what's going to happen is some folks are going to chime in and say something like "I keep my Rams at 74 and they do just fine for me."

Well sometimes you can successfully keep them in cooler temperatures but you will NEVER breed them at lower temperatures and it is VERY risky keeping them cool.  Certain fish just like it warm and Rams are one of them.

Another thing that can kill Rams is feeding them bloodworms. I have personally seen whole tanks of 100 or more Rams in them roll over and die after just one feeding of frozen bloodworms. It doesn't always happen but it happens often enough to where I would NEVER feed Rams bloodworms under any circumstances. 

I have sold at least 100 mated Pr's. of Rams this year alone and I find them to be incredibly hardy and easy to spawn IF I KEEP THEM HOT. And by easy I mean easier than convict cichlids and I am not even kidding. In fact, I actually think the Rams I have been buying from one breeder down in Florida are the perfect type of egglayer for beginners to attempt to breed IF THEY KEEP THEM HOT!


http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v455/lotsoffish/alotsoffish/cooltext14821207.gif   

Last edited by lotsoffish (2010-07-21 00:03:06)


If you don't stand for something, you'll fall for anything.
Stamp out morons!

Online

 

#11 2010-07-21 03:11:49

rbeauchemin
Member
From: Hohenfels, Germany
Registered: 2010-05-19
Posts: 298
IP: 217.237.17.106
Website

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Thank goodness.   Enjoyed your HOT post lotsoffish - I have a newly planted 30gal that I'm waiting for the plants to fill in on, and since the heater is under the substrate, it needs the plants to absorb that heat.  The water is running at 84-86 and I tossed some guppies in there to drop, and then I left the fry in there to grow out, and I was wondering if I was some sort of horrible sinner since everyone kept posting numbers in the 70s as 'right'.  I'm still new to this, but I can watch the fish and I swear they adore the warmth, and the mothers all dropped the second day after I purchased them, so it seemed like they liked it too.

*whew* !  I'll take that post as more correct seeing where it came from.

thanks!


If you have it, share it.  If you need it, pray for it.  If you want it, work for it.

For out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks!!

Offline

 

#12 2010-07-21 03:24:23

Goober
Member
From: Where cowards fear to tread
Registered: 2007-07-27
Posts: 2343
IP: 75.13.66.78

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a85/AquabidsGoober/ballbusting/cooltext66872035.gif


If I've offended you in any way , please take a ticket , get in line , and take a bite outta my (_o_)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i1MbM6D6 … re=related

Offline

 

#13 2010-07-21 04:48:22

BettaBetta
Member
From: Australia
Registered: 2010-03-22
Posts: 909
IP: 58.174.0.252

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

OMG LotsOfFish, thanks ever so much - would you believe I had defrosted some frozen bloodworms, added x 10 drops of Avitrol-Plus (Avian Wormer) that I intended to feed to them tomorrow morning, phew, down the sink they go. 

Right, I'm heading out to turn the temp up right now, that makes it, holy heck, 28.8888889 in my language - hopes everyone else in the tank will be ok with that - I will go up a degree a day.

Hmm what the heck is "whirling disease" - I noticed one of my new Otos behaving in a weird manner yesterday, doing acrobatics like a mad thing & found one dead this morning, as well as a new Blue Ram that I bought on the w/end just gone.  I immediately did a 60% waterchange & everyone seems fine.

Last edited by BettaBetta (2010-07-21 04:48:45)


Not usually a charitable soul?  At Kiva.org you can give "hand-ups" (loans) instead of "hand-outs" to the poor in 3rd world countries & the funds ALWAYS remain yours, to withdraw or re-loan as you see fit.  It's the BEST!!!  You can even loan to those involved in aquaculture.

Offline

 

#14 2010-07-21 14:12:23

shermlock
Member
From: Michigan
Registered: 2010-06-25
Posts: 127
IP: 68.61.142.96

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

I just looked up the bloodworms thing and those sources say that dwarfs have trouble digesting them...I've never had trouble with mine but I won't do it anymore!!! I need to find something else that they like now!

Last edited by shermlock (2010-07-21 14:12:57)


I'm pretty much a life long fish dork. I am currently working with trophs, guppies, swords, rams and cores.

Even after all the horrible seasons (not to mention an an O'fer), terrible drafts, and the yearly shattering of my dreams, I'm still a lifelong Lions fan.

Offline

 

#15 2010-07-22 02:44:31

BettaBetta
Member
From: Australia
Registered: 2010-03-22
Posts: 909
IP: 58.174.0.252

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Jasus Mary & Joseph, yesterday when adjusting the heater temp I forgot to plug it back in so we plummeted down to 23C gaaarrrgh. 

It's now back up to 28C (usually sits on 25/26C) and I have to say that the Rams appear much, much happier, they're scooting around the entire tank now instead of huddling in corners or plants.  Their little mouths are still opening & closing rapidly but I've come to the conclusion that all Rams do that naturally, it's just them.  Their gils aren't flapping & they're as happy as Larry now so thanks a million everyone (for the great PM's) & to you LOF, you saved their little a$$es food & temp wise champ.


Not usually a charitable soul?  At Kiva.org you can give "hand-ups" (loans) instead of "hand-outs" to the poor in 3rd world countries & the funds ALWAYS remain yours, to withdraw or re-loan as you see fit.  It's the BEST!!!  You can even loan to those involved in aquaculture.

Offline

 

#16 2010-07-22 06:58:46

anura630
Member
From: PA
Registered: 2007-08-28
Posts: 301
IP: 71.181.243.187

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

lotsoffish wrote:

[b]Another thing that can kill Rams is feeding them bloodworms. I have personally seen whole tanks of 100 or more Rams in them roll over and die after just one feeding of frozen bloodworms. It doesn't always happen but it happens often enough to where I would NEVER feed Rams bloodworms under any circumstances.

Pete is so right , I lost an entire tank, 6 pairs, of Blue Rams from feeding them frozen blood worms. It was a horrible experience and I felt so helpless as I sat there and watched them die. I had feed them the same blood worm(cubes)many times before, but this time something went terribly wrong.

Now I only buy Hikari brand blood worms and I never feed them to my Rams. Lesson learned: feeding blood worms to your rams is like playing Russian Roullette.

Offline

 

#17 2010-07-22 07:55:53

anura630
Member
From: PA
Registered: 2007-08-28
Posts: 301
IP: 71.181.243.187

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

BettaBetta wrote:

Hmm what the heck is "whirling disease" - I noticed one of my new Otos behaving in a weird manner yesterday, doing acrobatics like a mad thing & found one dead this morning, as well as a new Blue Ram that I bought on the w/end just gone.  I immediately did a 60% waterchange & everyone seems fine.

I was curious so I looked it up, whirling disease is a caused by a parasite (Myxosoma cerebralis). Here's a video of a infected young trout showing the typical "whirling" movements:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S5a0Grry … r_embedded

Sorry about your fishie troubles, I hope it's just a temp/food issue.

Michele

Offline

 

#18 2010-07-22 19:24:01

lauraleellbp
Member
From: Naples, FL
Registered: 2010-04-27
Posts: 38
IP: 67.239.8.1

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

I kept Rams for several years in my 90gal and yep, they definitely breathe faster than most other fish.  As long as they're active, eating, and showing good color, they should be fine.  IME an unhealthy Ram will lose color and hide all the time.

It's not a bad idea to worm and de-parasitze them, though- I actually do this with every fish I get (I make the assumption that unless a fish has been wormed, it's got worms- same as with dogs and cats).  Raw crushed garlic can do a good job with parasites, especially if you chop/mix it in with some frozen food.

If you got captive bred stock (which is most likely) your water parameters should be OK.

I never had any issues feeding bloodworms to mine, but I also stick with Hikari brand frozen food since I know Hikari uses a sterile process with their frozen foods. 

Frozen mysis were the food that my Rams did the best with, though I rotate all my fish between a good staple flake, frozen bloodworms, mysis, brine shrimp, and fresh veggies, rarely ever feeding the same thing 2 days in a row.

And I agree that they'll stay healthier with the tank in the low to mid-80s- my tank runs 80-82F and my rams spawned like clockwork every 2 weeks.

Keep an eye on your Ram/betta interactions- sometimes they can get aggressive with each other.

Last edited by lauraleellbp (2010-07-22 19:25:41)

Offline

 

#19 2010-07-22 22:35:07

BettaBetta
Member
From: Australia
Registered: 2010-03-22
Posts: 909
IP: 58.174.0.252

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Many thanks Laura, I add the minced garlic from the jar to the dry food & let it soak overnight, it seems to send everyone into a feeding frenzy.  I must say though, I've always been highly skeptical of the powers of garlic when it comes to worming cats, dogs, kids.  I guess with fish the reality is we never see worms expelled, unless of course it's the camallanus ones so one could never say with any degree of accuracy if garlic does in fact work for fish - I give it because they love it and hope that it has some benefit.

Yeppers to rotating all the good foods, although my Rams are the only ones in the tank who don't go for fruit or vegetables, everyone else goes silly for them.

Fortunately my Betta's are all sooks but if I was to get one who didn't get on the with the Rams I'd just keep swapping them all around until I found one who did, or give up & have it just Rams & their buddies only.

Oh, and I loved your landscape barrier idea in the Val thread.   I'll be implementing that for sure in my new tank I'm setting up in a few weeks, will do it all at the time of laying the substrate for sake of ease & convenience so thanks ever so much for that great tip.


Not usually a charitable soul?  At Kiva.org you can give "hand-ups" (loans) instead of "hand-outs" to the poor in 3rd world countries & the funds ALWAYS remain yours, to withdraw or re-loan as you see fit.  It's the BEST!!!  You can even loan to those involved in aquaculture.

Offline

 

#20 2010-07-29 13:25:47

Msdevine
Member
Registered: 2009-02-09
Posts: 1366
IP: 173.172.167.39

Re: Rams - Need help please ....

Ok, I read somewhere that u worm your fish with garlic??? How do you go about it? with fresh? I have some in the frig., that is bottled. NOT fresh,


I Live In My Own Little World,   But its ok "THEY" Know Me There.

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB

Vote For Us

Member of  AquaBanners.com